Tapco USB Interface Monitoring Problem

Monitoring levels lower than playback

I am using a Tapco USB interface and using the audio playback through the Tapco during live recording. The problem is that the sound in the headphones is much different than after I record it and play it back through the headphones. When recording the eq is real bassy and the volume is very low, when I play it back it sounds “live”. I would like to hear the same sound when recording that I hear at playback…duh. Anyone have a fix?